Minneapolis vs. Portland: The Battle Continues

Anyone watching this year’s NCAA basketball tournament can tell you that rankings mean nothing.  This year, all four number one seeds have been sent packing by lower ranked teams.

How is this relevant to Twin Cities cycling?

As all of you are aware, last year Minneapolis was named the #1 cycling city in the United States by the oh-so-wise editors of bicycling magazine.  This shook the people of Portland to the core, because honestly, what else do they have going for them?  This also put a target on our back because Portland is looking to re-take the lead.

Let’s take a look at a few of the big things that the City of Minneapolis added to its resumé since last year’s announcement (which happened in early April).

1) Successful launch of Nice Ride MN. Can you believe that Minneapolis was named #1 even before Nice Ride was up and running full-tilt.  Since last year’s successful launch Nice Ride has been held up as the example of what is possible for bicycle sharing programs in the United States, that has to be worth something.

2) City of Minneapolis named bicycle friendly business (PDF Link). Yes, we know that the community of Portland is Platinum, while Minneapolis is lowly Silver, but as a business, the City of Minneapolis made the list… City of Portland?

So what has Portland been doing to keep up?

1) Claimed #1 in a report from the U.S. Department of Transportation. This report hit last week and caused Portlanders to crow, and at least one Minneapolis publication to declare that the “Golden Gear Era” is over.  But not so fast.  A closer look at the actual report (PDF Link) doesn’t really reach one grand conclusion like Oregon Live would like you to believe.  In fact, the narrow study, which only looked at six cities, was geared more towards pointing out why New York does not excel at promoting cycling like other cities. Oregon Live takes one quote from one small section of the study, which isn’t even located within the “Conclusion” section.  By the same token we could say that the paper named Minneapolis #1 (for availability of bike parking)!  Another area where Portland leads? The number of cycling commuters.  This looks at year round cycling numbers, all that we have to say about that is the lowest ever recorded temperature in the city of Portland? Minus three degrees, pfft, here in Minneapolis we call that Spring.

2) Claimed drafting the top cycling blogger. In a matter of hours, the city of Portland was abuzz with the prospect that cycling blogger BikeSnobNYC might become BikeSnobPDX. He has now reported that his consciousness has moved but his body remains in NYC (with tongue firmly planted in cheek).

As you can see, Minneapolis should clearly remain in the top spot, war over.


Hopefully everyone will take this for what it is, just some friendly jabs at our friends in Minneapolis west (Portland).  Honestly, the idea that you could objectively compare cycling cultures across multiple cities and declare a “winner” is ridiculous, but the fact that it might cause more people to pay attention to cycling, awesome.

This entry was posted in Humor, Nice Ride, Twin Cities Cyclist and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Minneapolis vs. Portland: The Battle Continues

  1. ambrown says:

    “minneapolis west?”

    oh, it’s on.

  2. MPLS Cyclist says:

    Maybe if we plowed the bike lanes, painted bike symbols in the bike lanes, or even made sure the bike lanes were painted we could be #1.

    When will we have something like this? http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3017/2631764671_d67627b0d3.jpg

  3. adventure! says:

    …all that we have to say about that is the lowest ever recorded temperature in the city of Portland? Minus three degrees, pfft, here in Minneapolis we call that Spring.

    Well, all I have to say to that is: Attempt to live through one of the Northwest’s drizzly and gray winters that go on forever, where everything around you turns to mold and mildew. It’s turned away a few Minneapo…Minnecucia..uh, whatever you call someone from Minneapolis.

    And we prefer to call Minneapolis “Winnipeg South”.

  4. Luke Francl says:

    Minneapolis should not be resting on its laurels. If you read the article (or bike in Portland), it’s pretty clear that Minneapolis got the nod for its extensive and hard-core cycling community, not for its bike infrastructure. Portland beats Minneapolis on infrastructure on pretty much every level, and the drivers there are almost unbelievably courteous to cyclists.

    While I enjoy RT Rybak’s boasting as much as the next Minneapolitan, I’m concerned about the “we’re number one” rhetoric from politicians. We have a LONG way to go to catch up to Portland infrastructure-wise, and a lot of mistakes (Hennepin Avenue, anyone?) to fix along the way.

  5. domotion2011 says:

    Minneapolis streets have just taken on a serious new dimension this Spring. We possibly have the worse road conditions in local history. Nothing to be proud of and certainly time to take caution. Maybe we could get Rybak to encourage Mark Dayton to invest in “streets for people” now that Dayton is backing public works projects like “stadiums for people” for the Vikings.

    • Lowrah says:

      I have 311 on speed-dial for those pot holes.

      Although, secretly, I don’t mind the horrid road conditions in the day time when I can see the man-eating potholes. They make commuting more technical. ;]

  6. Ryan says:

    I live in Minneapolis and I bike all year round.

    Honestly, I think Minneapolis is kind of pushing it when they say they’re the most bike friendly, because:
    – they don’t even plow enough for the cars in the winter, you think all those new bike lanes that put them on the top of the list are going to be clear? forget it, they’re closed about 5 months out of the year because of the weather.

    I’ve never biked in portland, but there’s so many a-holes that cut you off in the cities when you have the right of way on a bike..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s